In Episode 4: “Dirty Little Secrets,” the investigation takes a dramatic turn when St. Tammany Parish Chief Pathologist, Dr. Michael DeFatta, reveals critical findings from Donna Arceneaux’s autopsy, proving her death was a homicide, not a suicide. Dr. DeFatta’s on-site visit confirms a suspicious detail—the position of Donna’s body suggested foul play. The episode also delves into darker revelations, uncovering secrets Donna may have been keeping about powerful figures in town. As Tucker follows these leads, the case deepens, raising questions about who Donna might have crossed and how far people would go to keep those secrets hidden.

Evidence in this Episode

Disclaimer:
The following is some of the evidence we can share with you from this episode. However, certain pieces of evidence have been reserved to ensure the integrity of the investigation and to protect the ability to prosecute the case.

Episode 4

Tucker Simmons investigates the unsolved murder of Donna Arceneaux in Louisiana

You can find a transcript of episode 4 here.